The Cost-Benefit Analysis of Bathtub Refinishing vs. Replacement

Deciding between bathtub refinishing and replacement is more than a mere choice; it’s a significant decision that impacts both your wallet and daily life. 

Imagine stepping into your bathroom each morning, facing a bathtub that’s either a gleaming testament to smart, cost-effective decision-making or a reminder of a potentially costly and disruptive project. 

The stakes are high, and the options are laid out before you. 

This analysis aims to guide you through the intricate details of bathtub refinishing versus replacement, providing you with the necessary information to make an informed decision that aligns with your needs, budget, and lifestyle.

Understanding Bathtub Refinishing

Bathtub refinishing, also known as reglazing or resurfacing, is a process that breathes new life into your existing tub. 

It involves repairing any damage, preparing the surface, and applying new coating materials. This method can address issues like stains, small cracks, and a dull finish, transforming your bathtub into a shiny, like-new condition.

The Cost Aspect

The cost of bathtub refinishing varies depending on the condition of your tub and the professional you choose. 

On average, homeowners can expect to spend between $300 and $600 for a standard refinishing job. This price range makes refinishing an attractive option for those looking to update their bathroom without undertaking a major renovation project.

The Benefits

  • Cost Efficiency: Refinishing is significantly less expensive than replacing a bathtub, often costing a fraction of the price of a new tub and installation.
  • Time-Saving: A refinishing project can usually be completed in a day or two, minimizing disruption to your daily routine.
  • Versatility: Refinishing allows you to update the look of your bathtub without the limitations of existing sizes and styles that come with replacement.

Exploring Bathtub Replacement

Replacing your bathtub involves removing the old tub and installing a new one. This option is often considered when the bathtub is extensively damaged, or a complete bathroom remodel is desired.

The Cost Dimension

The cost of bathtub replacement can be steep, ranging from $1,500 to $5,000 or more, including the price of the new tub and the labor for removal and installation. This range can vary widely based on the type of tub you select and the complexity of the installation process.

The Advantages

  • Comprehensive Solution: Replacement is ideal for dealing with severe damage or when a different size or style of bathtub is desired.
  • Increased Home Value: A new bathtub can enhance the overall appeal of your bathroom, potentially increasing your home’s market value.
  • Customization: Replacement offers the opportunity to customize your bathroom layout and design to your exact specifications.

Making the Decision: Refinishing vs. Replacement

When weighing the options, consider the following factors:

  • Budget: Refinishing is the more budget-friendly option, offering significant savings over replacement.
  • Condition of Your Current Tub: If your tub is in relatively good condition with cosmetic flaws, refinishing is a practical choice. For tubs that are severely damaged or outdated, replacement might be the better route.
  • Renovation Goals: Think about your long-term goals for your bathroom. If you’re planning a complete remodel or desire a different bathtub style or size, replacement aligns with those objectives.


The decision between bathtub refinishing and replacement hinges on a balance of cost, convenience, and personal preferences. 

Bathtub refinishing emerges as a cost-effective, efficient solution for those looking to refresh their bathroom without the extensive costs and disruptions of a full replacement. 

It’s an ideal choice for homeowners seeking to maximize the value of their existing fixtures while achieving a fresh, new look.

For those considering the path of bathtub refinishing, Tub Doctor of Augusta stands ready to assist. We also offer financing should you require a full remodel. With a deep-rooted presence in the local community since 1982, our commitment to providing swift, on-site estimates, and expediting remodeling or repair projects sets us apart. 

Unlike many refinishing and remodeling services that operate as satellite offices, our full-time dedication to the area ensures quick access to products and services, making your bathtub refinishing project a smooth and efficient endeavor.

Ready to transform your bathroom with a custom bathtub refinishing solution?

Get a quote from Tub Doctor of Augusta today and take the first step towards a beautifully refinished bathtub that combines both elegance and practicality.